Why Orlando Trusts the O’Mara Law Group for DUI Manslaughter Cases

Orlando families turn to O'Mara Law Group because founding attorney Mark O'Mara spent years as an Assistant State Attorney in Seminole County before building a defense practice, and is now Board Certified in Criminal Trial Law by The Florida Bar, a distinction held by an estimated 1% of practicing Florida attorneys. That combination of prosecutorial insight and trial credentials is what a DUI manslaughter case demands: an attorney who knows how the state builds these cases and how to take them apart, from the statutory definition and the causation element prosecutors must prove, through sentencing exposure and the defense strategies available at every stage.

How Florida Law Defines DUI Manslaughter

Florida law defines DUI manslaughter under Florida Statute § 316.193(3) as a single offense built from three parts:
Operating a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or with a blood-alcohol or breath-alcohol level of .08 or higher

  • That operation causing or contributing to causing the death of a person or an unborn child
  • The two connected: the impairment itself, not just the driving, is what leads to the fatality

The statute makes DUI manslaughter its own offense rather than treating a fatality as a simple sentencing enhancement on top of a standard DUI, and that distinction carries real weight in how each case is defended:

  • A standard DUI charge only requires the state to prove impaired or unlawful driving
  • DUI manslaughter adds a second, separate requirement: that the impaired driving is what caused the death
  • Because the state carries a heavier burden, defense arguments that would not apply to an ordinary DUI case can come into play, particularly around whether the impairment itself, rather than some other factor, caused the fatal outcome
police caution tape

What Must Prosecutors Prove in a DUI Manslaughter Case?

Prosecutors must prove three separate elements to convict someone of DUI manslaughter under Florida law:

  1. The person was driving, or in actual physical control of, a vehicle;
  2. The person's normal faculties were impaired by alcohol or drugs, or their blood-alcohol or breath-alcohol level was .08 or higher; and
  3. The person's operation of the vehicle caused or contributed to the death of another person

That third element, causation, is usually where these cases are won or lost. It is not enough for the state to show that a driver had been drinking and that a crash occurred; prosecutors have to draw a direct line between the impairment and the fatality. Toxicology timing, accident reconstruction, roadway conditions, and the actions of other drivers involved in the crash can all affect whether the state can actually establish that link.

Real Client Testimonial

They were very communicative and even spoke to me after hours which I truly appreciated. I would highly recommend them.

S.D.

Get the Legal Help You Need Now.

Contact us media

What Are the Penalties for a Florida DUI Manslaughter Conviction?

  • Second-degree felony (baseline): Charged under Florida Statute § 316.193(3), punishable by up to 15 years in prison and up to $10,000 in fines under Florida Statutes §§ 775.082–775.084.
  • Mandatory minimum sentence: The same statute imposes a mandatory minimum term of imprisonment of four years for anyone convicted, meaning a judge has no discretion to impose a shorter prison term, regardless of the surrounding circumstances.
  • First-degree felony (escalated charge): Punishable by up to 30 years in prison, if the driver knew or should have known that a crash occurred and failed to give information or render aid as required under Florida Statute § 316.062.
  • License and record consequences: Beyond incarceration, a conviction brings permanent driver's license revocation and a felony record. Under Florida Statute § 943.0585, expunction is available only to someone who was never adjudicated guilty, so a DUI manslaughter conviction cannot be expunged from a person's criminal record.
Pattern media

Common Defense Strategies in DUI Manslaughter Cases

Because a DUI manslaughter conviction depends on the state proving causation, many defense strategies focus on breaking that link between impairment and the fatality, rather than disputing that a crash occurred. O'Mara Law Group's attorneys evaluate every DUI manslaughter case for defenses that may include:

  • Arguing that an intervening cause, such as another driver's actions, a mechanical failure, or a road hazard, actually caused the crash
  • Challenging whether the traffic stop or arrest was supported by reasonable suspicion or probable cause
  • Questioning the accuracy, calibration, or administration of breath, blood, or urine test results
  • Identifying breaks in the chain of custody for blood or breath evidence
  • Reviewing the state's accident reconstruction for errors in timeline, speed, or point-of-impact analysis

No two DUI manslaughter cases raise identical facts, so which of these strategies applies, if any, depends on the specific evidence gathered in a given case.

Is DUI Manslaughter a Felony in Florida?

DUI manslaughter is always charged as a felony in Florida, with no misdemeanor version of the offense. At minimum, it is a second-degree felony under Florida Statute § 316.193(3), and it becomes a first-degree felony when the driver knew or should have known about the crash and failed to report it or render aid. That felony classification is what triggers the mandatory minimum prison term and the permanent inability to expunge the conviction.

Banner media
Our firm media

Why Choose the DUI Manslaughter Attorneys at O'Mara Law Group in Orlando, FL?

A DUI manslaughter charge in Florida can carry life-altering consequences, making experienced legal representation essential. At O'Mara Law Group, our DUI manslaughter attorneys in Orlando have decades of combined experience defending clients against serious criminal charges. We understand the complexity of cases involving allegations of impaired driving and a fatal accident, and we work to protect our clients' rights at every stage of the legal process. Our knowledge of Florida criminal law and extensive courtroom experience allow us to build a defense tailored to the circumstances of each case.

  • Mark O'Mara, founding partner, is one of the few attorneys in Florida board-certified in both Criminal Trial Law and Marital and Family Law. His extensive trial experience includes representing clients facing serious criminal charges with potentially life-changing consequences.
  • Our attorneys have been recognized as Super Lawyers and Top 100 Trial Lawyers, reflecting our commitment to dedicated client representation and strong advocacy in complex criminal cases.

If you or a loved one has been charged with DUI manslaughter, contact O'Mara Law Group today to schedule a confidential consultation. Our team is prepared to defend your rights and help you navigate the challenges ahead.

Learn More About Our Attorneys

DUI Manslaughter FAQs

Does DUI manslaughter require proof that I was intoxicated?

Yes. Prosecutors must show that a driver's normal faculties were impaired by alcohol or drugs, or that their blood-alcohol or breath-alcohol level was .08 or higher, under Florida Statute § 316.193. Impairment alone is not enough on its own; the state must also connect that impairment to the death.

Can I be charged with DUI manslaughter if my BAC was below 0.08?

Yes. Florida's DUI statute allows a charge based on impaired "normal faculties" even when BAC registers below .08, provided the state has other evidence of impairment, such as field sobriety test results or an officer's observations. A specific BAC reading is not required to face DUI manslaughter charges.

Can a DUI manslaughter charge be dismissed?

Depending on the facts, a charge can potentially be reduced or dismissed, including over problems with the traffic stop, the reliability of chemical testing, or whether the state can actually prove that impairment caused the death. Whether dismissal is realistic depends entirely on the evidence in a specific case, which is why an early, independent investigation matters.

What if another driver caused the crash?

When another driver's actions, rather than the defendant's impairment, actually caused the fatal collision, that can undercut the causation element that prosecutors must prove. An attorney can investigate the crash independently, including through accident reconstruction, to determine whether an intervening cause affected the outcome.

How long does a DUI manslaughter case take in Florida?

Timelines vary widely depending on the complexity of the evidence, whether the defense requests independent testing or expert review, and whether the case is resolved through a plea or proceeds to trial. Felony cases involving a fatality often take longer than standard DUI cases because of the additional investigation involved.

Will I have to go to trial?

Not necessarily. Many DUI manslaughter cases resolve through negotiation rather than trial, but O'Mara Law Group's attorneys prepare every case as though it will go to trial so a client is not at a disadvantage if negotiations do not lead to an acceptable resolution.

Why do I need a DUI manslaughter defense attorney?

A DUI manslaughter conviction carries a mandatory minimum prison sentence, permanent license revocation, and a felony record that cannot later be expunged, so the stakes are significantly higher than in a standard DUI case. An attorney who understands both the criminal charge and the underlying accident investigation can identify defenses a driver would not recognize on their own.

Contact us media
Accessibility: If you are vision-impaired or have some other impairment covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act or a similar law, and you wish to discuss potential accommodations related to using this website, please contact our Accessibility Manager at (407) 898-5151.
Contact Us